IAIN ROBERTSON

BMW i

BMW i

Tesla has not exactly been helpful to the EV industry, writes Iain Robertson, by announcing that its Models S and X will be provided with FREE electricity, when there is a cost implication to be borne, as the following report highlights succinctly.

Buying into the Electrified Vehicle market, which is growing very slowly but assuredly, has raised a number of issues. Whether your vehicle choice is hybrid or full EV, its real term ‘clean’ status can only be so, if you are also recharging its battery pack with renewable electricity, which is obtained by wind, or solar power, at this time. Electricity obtained from a fossil-fuel-fired power station, whether by oil, coal, or gas, is only moving the blame a little further along the line.

EVs List of cheapest to recharge

EVs List of cheapest to recharge

While many suppliers of hybrid and EV motor vehicles may have been provided with an ‘incentive’ card, which would allow them pre-paid access (in some cases, strictly time limited) to the public charging network, somebody will still be footing the bill. Electricity is not free, neither is it that inexpensive; yes, it is great value but, just look at your domestic fuel bill for the answer.

While EVs may well be the future of low-emission transportation, hybrids are proving to provide an increasingly popular compromise. Recent government research found that nearly three quarters of British motorists (74%) claimed that initial high costs of electric or hybrid vehicles stop them in their tracks. More than half (52%) felt that re-charging the vehicle is a turn-off.

Peugeot PHEV

Peugeot PHEV

Private registration-plates company, Click4reg.co.uk, collated data for current hybrid vehicles using Zap-Map’s ‘Public Charging Calculator’ tool and analysed which cars cost the least to power-up at public charge points, for which I am delighted, as it saved me the effort. The findings were amazing, with the least expensive car to recharge being the very expensive BMW i8 (£1.25 to add 59 miles), which also has the fastest recharge time of 1.4 hours at 3kW public charging points.

The i8 is followed by both the Mercedes-Benz C-Class Estate and the E-Class Saloon (£1.49 to ‘refuel’, around 1.7 hours for 59 miles). Selling for anything between £650,000 and £1m, the Porsche 918 Spyder provides a shock (£1.63, 1.8 hours). Meanwhile, the Mini Cooper Countryman (£1.82, 2 hours) is followed by the BMW 3-Series saloon (£1.85, 2.1 hours), all for a 59 miles range.

DEV Optima PHEV

DEV Optima PHEV

Click4reg.co.uk also revealed the notable dual-energy (hybrid) cars that ranked among the cheapest vehicles to ‘re-juice’ at public charging points: VW Golf (£2.09, 2.3 hours), Toyota Prius Plug-In (£2.11, 2.3 hours) and the Kia Optima Plug-In Hybrid (£2.35, 2.6 hours). Unsurprisingly, fully electric vehicles are more expensive to charge, with the Tesla costing between £13-18 per charge, dependent on model, and the Hyundai KONA Electric costing £9.41 for an effective charge that took a whopping 10.5 hours.

Yet, the company discovered that the following fully electric vehicles all cost under £5 to charge at 3kW public charging points (longer charging times than hybrid vehicles):

Car Cost of Charge Charging Time
Mitsubishi i-MiEV £3.84 4.3 hrs
Peugeot iOn £3.84 4.3 hrs
Smart fortwo coupe £4.22 4.7 hrs
VW e-UP! £4.49 5 hrs
BMW i3 £4.51 5 hrs

 

Conclusion:      Remember that some truths are only as transparent as the marketing paper upon which they are printed. Before you reach your decision on EVs and hybrids, take time to speak with a professional, or do some more intense research.

DEV Volvo V

DEV Volvo V